Andrea Norton wrote "The Gate of the Cat" in 1987 and it was published as an Ace book by the Berkley Publishing Group as ISBN: 0-441-27380-7. It is part of her extensive Witch World series.
- This echos the first book of the series, "Witch World" where Simon Tregarth of our world chooses to pass irrevocably through a gate into the Witch World where he finds unusual powers and a wife. However, Kelsie accidentally passes through in company with a Wild Cat (who is the only agent who seems to understand what is going on), ends up with a witch's lens, and uncertainly finds a mate Yonan, and uncertainly decides to accept staying. She is wearisome to read about.
- However, at the end, she wins her way with Yonan and with Wittle, a power-crazed orthodox witch, to a place where a valley basin shows a miniature model of the lands of Escarrp and Escore, even including its own miniature model. There, shafts of power strengthen the Dark areas, or weaken them, and we realize that the model is a true Homolog of the world of action. It reminded me of the Layers of walled garden at the end of C. S. Lewis' "The Last Battle" where within each garden of paradise is a larger, more real one. However, this Homolog is static, and at the end seems to map to itself, rather than a more glorious land.
- The blue-white rays of the Light seesaw with the red rays of the Dark, driven by a nameless dancer who generates the red with "some strange formal dance". Yonan vanishes into the basin, and the wildcat forces Kelsie to enter it, returning to the place of sanctuary, the Valley of the Green Silences. This is lovingly sketched as a rallying place for the Light in the land of Escore.
- Places and structures are judged by several senses. Color is a common one, with green and blue supporting the Light and yellow and red supporting the Dark. Stench indicates a place with different allegience, and this means for Kelsie, places of the Dark have a stench. For Kelsie, coldness indicates the Dark.
- I was disappointed when we meet Kemoc and Kyllan and their father Simon Tregarth, all heros of other books of the series. Robert Heinline has his heroes banter and reveal some of how they are doing when they meet from different story lines in "The Number of the Beast", but Andre Norton only sketches these figures. However, her sketches are evocative in general, making her a writer to return to. Heinline's interactions get heavy and cumbersome, and so I should accept my disappointment as the price for meeting the characters.